The Traitors finale evaluation: Reality TV at its very best – perfectly orchestrated chaos

Sign as much as our free IndyArts e-newsletter for all the newest leisure information and critiques

Sign as much as our free IndyArts e-newsletter

The yr 2024 has not obtained off to an excellent begin: wars proceed to rage, local weather disasters ravage our blue planet, and politics divides neighbours, households, and pals. And but there was one nugget of optimism within the muddy silt of despair: the second collection of the BBC’s actuality TV sensation, The Traitors. Hosted by human fringe Claudia Winkleman and tailored from a Dutch format loosely based mostly on the after-dinner sport Mafia, The Traitors has gripped the nation over the previous few weeks. Twenty two contestants – unusual individuals from throughout the UK – holed up collectively in a Scottish fort, pressured right into a tango of deceit and interrogation: what could possibly be higher?

And then, in tonight’s closing episode, there have been 5. Leading the road for the finalists was Traitor Harry, who has develop into the present’s breakout star following his ruthless patricide towards ginger agent of darkness, Paul. Then there was his confederate, Andrew, a Welsh bodybuilder who has defied the chances to outlive his position as cannon fodder for the away workforce. And then, on the facet of the Faithfuls, an unholy trinity led by Jaz, who everybody appears satisfied is a cretin regardless of his constantly insightful accusations. “We’ve made some mistakes, haven’t we?” noticed fellow Faithful Mollie, which is placing it frivolously. And, lastly, there was Evie – “the only Scottish finalist” as she describes herself – who has spent the collection sneaking by way of spherical after spherical underneath the duvet of narrative obscurity.

This yr, now that the format is extra established and scrutinised, it’s clear that The Traitors has mastered a type of excellent imperfection. The sport itself makes little to no sense: the Faithfuls this yr managed to appropriately uncover 4 totally different Traitors at the night roundtables, but nonetheless needed to face off towards two Traitors within the closing. It renders the primary a number of rounds of the sport primarily pointless. The primary technique continues to be to lie low, act dumb and hope that lack of suspicion, or intimidation, carries you all the best way to the showdown. There is a motive, maybe, why parlour video games don’t usually final for a number of days. No quantity of warbled indie covers of emo anthems can paper over these cracks in how the sport works.

And but, The Traitors pulls off its methods, largely as a result of it understands that the essence of any good actuality TV is human psychodrama. The thrill of I’m a Celebrity is just not seeing individuals carry out the fascinating activity of consuming kangaroo testicle, however witnessing how individuals psychologically deal with the specter of marsupial genitals. Big Brother, in the meantime, is basically the Stanford jail experiment; Rise and Fall, a rerun of Stanley Milgram’s notorious obedience checks. The Traitors is the apotheosis of this, a type of emotional sizzling boxing. In simply a few weeks, friendships have been cast and unforged, the stakes raised to a hysterical pitch. The prize pot, which ended up at £95,150, is hardly similar to the $4.5m supplied for successful Squid Game: The Challenge. And but they fought for it with the savagery of a jail riot. Back stabbings – and entrance stabbings – are ten a penny within the Traitors fort.

In the tip, all of it got here all the way down to Mollie. Trapped between a Traitor she trusted and a Faithful she had her doubts about, the higher angels of her nature gained out – to her detriment. It was Harry’s sport; it was all the time Harry’s sport. The collection’ climactic scene, the place Mollie realised what she’d performed, was actuality TV unfolding in perfectly orchestrated chaos. “You have played an extraordinary game,” Claudia advised Harry, after Mollie had swept off the set in tears. But actually, it was a unprecedented piece of casting. Finding this 22-year-old military engineer from Slough was the true miracle. “Now I’m just Harry again,” he noticed with reduction as his charade lastly got here to an finish. But, someway, it’s onerous to think about that this man – born tv gold – is ever going to be “just Harry” once more.